What?s wrong with ?Evidence Based? depression treatments?
What’s wrong with “Evidence Based” depression treatments?
Free Online Articles Directory
Why Submit Articles?
Top Authors
Top Articles
FAQ
AB Answers
0 && $.browser.msie ) {
var ie_version = parseInt($.browser.version);
if(ie_version Hello Guest
Login
Register
Hello
My Home
Sign Out
Email
Password
Remember me?
Lost Password?
Home Page > Health > Mental Health > What’s wrong with “Evidence Based” depression treatments?
What’s wrong with “Evidence Based” depression treatments?
Posted: Jun 25, 2009 |Comments: 0
|
]]>
With all our medical advances, why is it that the incidence of depression and anxiety is skyrocketing. The World Health Organisation says that depression is the most disabling disease in the Western World today, yet all mental healthcare specialists seem to talk about is “evidence based” treatments such as counselling and anti depressants. Whilst these strategies have been shown to be helpful for some people, if this was really cutting edge advice, why aren’t we seeing the incidence of depression declining or at the very least plateauing. This in no way seeks to imply that medication and psychological counselling don’t have their place in treating depression, just that we are not exploring all the variables
Having interviewed thousands of people who have battled with depression, I am convinced that there are some serious issues with the “evidence based” approach to treating depression. These can be summarised as follows:
The “evidence” is where the money is
Unfortunately clinical trials are very expensive to run so private funding will only be directed towards those areas where “investors” can see a return on investment. In the world of depression treatments, this means that the vast majority of funds are directed towards medication and psychological counselling interventions. This means that important lifestyle strategies such as exercise, emotional support,nutrition, relaxation, and fulfilling work are relatively ignored. Ironically these less discussed strategies can be much less costly to implement.
When you’re holding a hammer everything looks like a nail
The vast majority of depression treatment studies are undertaken by doctors or psychologists. Whilst there is nothing wrong with this per se, most of these studies are evaluating areas where they have expertise (which makes sense). This means that the comparisons are often looking in isolation at one drug verses another (or a placebo) or one psychological intervention verses another. Quite often meaningful advancements in areas can come from someone outside the established “paradigms”. I love the story of the little boy who came across rescue workers who had been struggling for 3 hours with sophisticated hydraulic equipment trying to dislodge a truck which had been tightly wedged under an overhead bridge. After being encouraged to leave the site he quietly said “Why don’t you let down the tyres?”.
We are not just DNA
As human beings our bodies and minds are intricately linked. Depression treatments that focus purely on a “biological illness” are seriously limited. Much of the despair that exists in the western world today can be linked to loneliness, family breakdowns, excessive and unfulfilling work, and financial crises. Saying that depression is caused by low levels of serotonin is like saying teen pregnancies are caused by a sperm fertilising an egg – yes, but…. Depression treatments that fail to reconnect us with our passions and purpose are ultimately going to be short lived solutions.
What are the right depression treatments?
To find out what works best in managing or overcoming depression, we must ask the people who are living with depression what works best for them. In 2007 I asked just that, and their answers were (in order) exercise, support of family and friends, psychological counselling, fulfilling work, relaxation/meditation, nutrition and medication.
Coincidentally, the Black Dog Institute (BDI) –one of the pre-eminent mood disorder units in the world – also undertook a study directly asking those with depression what helped them most. Although there were some differences in the studies, lifestyle strategies were also shown to be extremely important. One of the authors of the published study, Professor Gordon Parker, who has been practicing psychiatry for over 30 years, has now started advising General Practitioners and their patients to exercise regularly to aid recovery.
If Professor Parker, who has published over 600 clinical papers and book chapters regarding mood disorders, can learn something from these results, perhaps we all can.
With all our medical advances, why is it that the incidence of depression and anxiety is skyrocketing. The World Health Organisation says that depression is the most disabling disease in the Western World today, yet all mental healthcare specialists seem to talk about is “evidence based” treatments such as counselling and anti depressants. Whilst these strategies have been shown to be helpful for some people, if this was really cutting edge advice, why aren’t we seeing the incidence of depression declining or at the very least plateauing. This in no way seeks to imply that medication and psychological counselling don’t have their place in treating depression, just that we are not exploring all the variables
Having interviewed thousands of people who have battled with depression, I am convinced that there are some serious issues with the “evidence based” approach to treating depression. These can be summarised as follows:
The “evidence” is where the money is
Unfortunately clinical trials are very expensive to run so private funding will only be directed towards those areas where “investors” can see a return on investment. In the world of depression treatments, this means that the vast majority of funds are directed towards medication and psychological counselling interventions. This means that important lifestyle strategies such as exercise, emotional support,nutrition, relaxation, and fulfilling work are relatively ignored. Ironically these less discussed strategies can be much less costly to implement.
When you’re holding a hammer everything looks like a nail
The vast majority of depression treatment studies are undertaken by doctors or psychologists. Whilst there is nothing wrong with this per se, most of these studies are evaluating areas where they have expertise (which makes sense). This means that the comparisons are often looking in isolation at one drug verses another (or a placebo) or one psychological intervention verses another. Quite often meaningful advancements in areas can come from someone outside the established “paradigms”. I love the story of the little boy who came across rescue workers who had been struggling for 3 hours with sophisticated hydraulic equipment trying to dislodge a truck which had been tightly wedged under an overhead bridge. After being encouraged to leave the site he quietly said “Why don’t you let down the tyres?”.
We are not just DNA
As human beings our bodies and minds are intricately linked. Depression treatments that focus purely on a “biological illness” are seriously limited. Much of the despair that exists in the western world today can be linked to loneliness, family breakdowns, excessive and unfulfilling work, and financial crises. Saying that depression is caused by low levels of serotonin is like saying teen pregnancies are caused by a sperm fertilising an egg – yes, but…. Depression treatments that fail to reconnect us with our passions and purpose are ultimately going to be short lived solutions.
What are the right depression treatments?
To find out what works best in managing or overcoming depression, we must ask the people who are living with depression what works best for them. In 2007 I asked just that, and their answers were (in order) exercise, support of family and friends, psychological counselling, fulfilling work, relaxation/meditation, nutrition and medication.
Coincidentally, the Black Dog Institute (BDI) –one of the pre-eminent mood disorder units in the world – also undertook a study directly asking those with depression what helped them most. Although there were some differences in the studies, lifestyle strategies were also shown to be extremely important. One of the authors of the published study, Professor Gordon Parker, who has been practicing psychiatry for over 30 years, has now started advising General Practitioners and their patients to exercise regularly to aid recovery.
If Professor Parker, who has published over 600 clinical papers and book chapters regarding mood disorders, can learn something from these results, perhaps we all can.
Retrieved from “http://www.articlesbase.com/mental-health-articles/whats-wrong-with-evidence-based-depression-treatments-993321.html”
(ArticlesBase SC #993321)
Liked this article? Click here to publish it on your website or blog, it’s free and easy!
Graeme Cowan -
About the Author:
Graeme Cowan battled depression himself before writing BACK FROM THE BRINK and BACK FROM THE BRINK TOO. Free copies of his depression treatment and the BDI research mentioned in the article can be found at: www.IamBackFromTheBrink.com
]]>
Questions and Answers
Ask our experts your Mental Health related questions here…200 Characters left
How is evidence based practice used in nursing ?
What is wrong if after 5 yrs of being clean i am still depressed,disinterested in work or my life and miss the girl ilost during addiction could this have anything to do withthe drugs that were taken
I have been refused an eea permit based on the fact that my husband- who is an eea national- and I live in Nigeria. What are we doing wrong?
Rate this Article
vote(s)
0 vote(s)
Feedback
RSS
Print
Email
Re-Publish
Article Tags:
depression treatment, depression cure
Latest Mental Health Articles
More from Graeme Cowan
Postpartum Depression Treatment Options – Riva’s Story
Reva shares if she was open to the treatment options provided for her postpartum depression/PPD symptoms. (02:30)
In this medical video learn how Botox may just help eliminate depression. (01:40)
In this medicinal video learn about how Ritalin, which is best known for treating hyperactive children, now may have a new use in helping seniors with depression. (01:36)
In this health video learn about over-the-phone treatment for depression. (01:36)
Depression can be debilitating, but with treatment, people suffering from the condition can notice marked reduction in symptoms. (02:29)
anxiety headache – anxiety depression treatment – depression men
anxiety headache – anxiety depression treatment – depression men
By:
ninl
Health>
Diseases and Conditionsl
May 26, 2010
Your Depression Treatment Options
Depression can be a very serious illness, which threatens and effects the lives of millions of people around the world.
By:
Robert Kokoskal
Health>
Diseases and Conditionsl
May 27, 2008
Depression Treatment: Must Read for Everyone
Depression treatments should address the problems faced by the patients. A mutual understanding will help the people to gain confidence on each other.
By:
Daniel Marcus Mansonl
Healthl
Aug 04, 2009
Finding the right Depression Treatment
Depression or prolonged sadness is actually quite common in the United States, around 9.5 percent of the American population actually suffers from this illness, however, not all of them get to be treated, thus, depression and its ill-effects continue to be a burden to some individuals.
By:
Kevin Regierl
Self Improvement>
Self Helpl
Dec 10, 2009
Anxiety and Depression Treatment and Natural Home remedies to get rid of Anxiety Depression
Depression is an illness that involves body, mind and thoughts. It is not a physical weakness that will vanish within days but it’s the state that interferes with the daily chores of life resulting in poor performance or output. It gives rise to a negative feeling for each and every thing. It may also be defined as allergy, which triggers an unhappy reaction. It may be due to emotional or mental stress and strain or due to high intake of antibiotics. Sometimes anxiety also results in depression
By:
drcharlesbucharl
Health>
Wellnessl
Aug 20, 2010
The great need of alleviating a depressive disorder using a trustworthy depression treatment center
Depression Treatment Centers have a wide range of things to see, just before starting the therapy of a subject.
By:
Jeffrey T. Millerl
Health>
Wellnessl
Sep 21, 2010
Depression Treatment has got a new face with Malibu
If you are suffering from excessive depression and finding no proper remedy or counseling to overcome it then you can try for Malibu depression treatment center, which is specialized in total recovering of depressions of the sufferers. If your close associate is suffering from depression, be 100% sure that the kind of treatment offered with utmost care being taken here is at par living at home with the family persons
By:
Jarrod jonesl
Health>
Medicinel
Dec 23, 2009
Nursing Courses are to educates an individual with the expansion of healthcare
Anyone want to choose courses or jobs that offer a guarantee for them to succeed in life, they will do a thorough research into their choice of education which will help them get highly paid. Few people go with the choice of their parents or go with the courses that they believe provide the facilities to their hometown and also from other countries.
By:
rajendral
Health>
Mental Healthl
Jan 05, 2011
Lavender Oil As a Treatment for Burns
Starting to eat better will be a big help while you are working to get rid of cellulite.
By:
Alex smithl
Health>
Mental Healthl
Jan 05, 2011
BBG Communications – Mental Health is Important
Some English expressions are only that – expressions. However, what if some could be taken literally, like bottling emotions would help the mental health field dramatically. It has already been done with scent in perfumes. Why not with emotions? With the technology based scientific field of today, anything is possible.
Health>
Mental Healthl
Jan 05, 2011
Glossophobia – Fear of Public Speaking
Glossophobia, or the fear of public speaking, is extremely typical. In fact, some experts estimate that as many as 3 out of 4 people have some level of anxiety regarding public speaking. Of course, numerous individuals have the ability to deal with and manage the fear. If your fear is considerable sufficient to trigger troubles in work, school or social settings, then it is possible that you suffer from a full blown phobia.
By:
Tracy D. Rybackl
Health>
Mental Healthl
Jan 04, 2011
Eagle Ranch Academy Has Exemplary Residential Programs for Youth
Eagle Ranch Academy’s is a residential treatment program for troubled youth, whose overwhelmingly comprehensive approach to care has been noted by organizations like Answers for Parents and StrugglingTeen.net.
By:
Mel Joellel
Health>
Mental Healthl
Jan 04, 2011
Using Hypnotherapy to Treat a Phobia
First of all, what is a phobia? A phobia is the persistent fear of a certain thing such as an event, a situation, a simple activity, an object, an animal, or a certain person. The fear involved is often irrational and intense.
By:
Jared D. Ingraml
Health>
Mental Healthl
Jan 04, 2011
Read this article for some helpful information about stress and stress management therapy.
By:
Topcho Rabevl
Health>
Mental Healthl
Jan 04, 2011
With drug use being so widely spread through all the pores of modern society, being healthy and drug free means much more than it may seem. It means turning down pressure imposed by peers, friends and sometimes even family members. It means not using drugs, and not feeling the tempting need to use drugs.
By:
Franol
Health>
Mental Healthl
Jan 04, 2011
Acceptance is the first step in Overcoming Depression and Anxiety
It is better to cure depression as fast as possible. Depression comes from many factors but first is to cure from within, since the more you feel bad the more you feel depressed. Improving self esteem, affirmations and admittance help to give you effective depression cure that works.
By:
Graeme Cowanl
Health>
Mental Healthl
Jul 07, 2009
lViews: 290
7 Essential Depression Treatments
The term “depression” encapsulates wide array of psychological conditions. The causes for depression are different and so are the symptoms. It is definitely not wise to treat the symptoms which provide temporary relief; one should address the causes so as to help the patient lead a more secured and fulfilling life.
By:
Graeme Cowanl
Health>
Mental Healthl
Jul 01, 2009
What’s wrong with “Evidence Based” depression treatments?
Most mental health care specialists advocate “evidence based” treatments such as counselling and anti depressants as the ideal form of depression cure. While these strategies do bear fruits for some individuals, the incidence of depression does not seem to decline at all.
By:
Graeme Cowanl
Health>
Mental Healthl
Jun 25, 2009
Add new Comment
Your Name: *
Your Email:
Comment Body: *
Verification code:*
* Required fields
Submit
Your Articles Here
It’s Free and easy
Sign Up Today
Author Navigation
My Home
Publish Article
View/Edit Articles
View/Edit Q&A
Edit your Account
Manage Authors
Statistics Page
Personal RSS Builder
My Home
Edit your Account
Update Profile
View/Edit Q&A
Publish Article
Author Box
Graeme Cowan has 3 articles online
Articles Categories
All Categories
Advertising
Arts & Entertainment
Automotive
Beauty
Business
Careers
Computers
Education
Finance
Food and Beverage
Health
Hobbies
Home and Family
Home Improvement
Internet
Law
Marketing
News and Society
Relationships
Self Improvement
Shopping
Spirituality
Sports and Fitness
Technology
Travel
Writing
Acne
Allergies
Alternative Medicine
Anti Aging
Cancer
Dental Care
Disabilities
Diseases and Conditions
Hair Loss
Hearing
Medical Tourism
Medicine
Men’s Health
Mental Health
Nutrition
Plastic Surgeries
Quit Smoking
Sleep
Supplements & Vitamins
Vision
Wellness
Women’s Health
]]>
Need Help?
Contact Us
FAQ
Submit Articles
Editorial Guidelines
Blog
Site Links
Recent Articles
Top Authors
Top Articles
Find Articles
Site Map
Webmasters
RSS Builder
RSS
Link to Us
Business Info
Advertising
Use of this web site constitutes acceptance of the Terms Of Use and Privacy Policy | User published content is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
Copyright © 2005-2011 Free Articles by ArticlesBase.com, All rights reserved.
Stress, Anxiety, and Depression
Nothing is quite as pervasive, perplexing, and personal as stress, anxiety, and depression. Dr. Coyle encourages you and assists you in understanding and choosing how you would like to approach these difficulties in your life. He offers guidance and explanation about various forms of treatment for these common problems including interpersonal therapy, cognitive-behavioral therapy, desensitization, mastery, and other fundamental interventions known to be most effective. An alternative to waiting in line for the next antidepressant, his review of various causes of depression is most helpful in restoring mastery, control, and hope to every individual. THE PRESENTER:
Additional information about Dr. Coyle can be found. He compassionately offers practical solutions founded in clinical practice and is committed to improving quality, access and economy of emotional health care through psychoeducation and partnership.
Many additional resources can be found at Mincluding innovative web-ba
Rating: 
(out of reviews)
List Price: $ 24.95
Price: $ 24.95
I am not a doctor and I am not suggesting that if you have depression and have only tried a few anti-depressants to go out and order this medication online. This is my story and what has helped for me. I currently take Tramadol also known as Ultram to treat my depression and anxiety. It is a non-narcotic pain medication that has similar effects on the brain as opiate painkillers. I was originally prescribed this for pain and it had no affect on the pain whatsoever but it did make me feel 100% better mentally and emotionally. Finding a doctor who will prescribe Tramadol for depression is basically near impossible. I discussed the research I did online about this with my doctor and he was willing to start me on Tramadol for depression. I have taken this for over 2 years and have not had to increase my dose or feel I have a tolerance. It doesn’t make you “high” or euphoric like hydrocodone based meds, it just makes ME feel normal. Some people have tried this and says it makes them feel worse. Everyone is different. But this has helped me when nothing else has. I have taken over 40 different medications in the last 12 years for depression, bipolar, anxiety, boarderline and had horrible side effects from them all. For those of you who take anti-depressants what has worked for you?
Video Rating: 5 / 5
Related Depression Treatment Articles
Related posts:
- Overcoming Depression: A Cognitive Therapy Approach Workbook (Treatments That Work) Reviews
- The Best Depression Treatments – Remedies Or Prescription Drugs?
- Depression treatments. Which treatment has worked for you?
- How to Give the Right Depression Treatment
- Willingness is the most important factor in COMMON ANXIETY OR DEPRESSION TREATMENT.?
- Choose Natural Depression Treatment and not Drugs!
- Your Depression Treatment Options
- Scientific research reveals brain alterations linking omega 3 deficit with depression
- Psychodynamic Treatment of Depression
- Depression Screening Tests are a Valuable Resource
Posted in 
Tags: